"A Guy Walks Into a Bar," Farr's followup to his No. 1 hit "Whiskey in My Water," tells of a man whose entire life is changed after hitting a pub. The song starts out on a high note as a love song, with Farr singing about how the bar changed the man's life for the good, and then goes somewhere unexpected.

The song ends up making a full circle with Farr singing: "A guy walks into a bar, orders a drink/ Sees a girl that catches his eye/Asks her if she wants another/ They fall for each other and end up lovers/ They laugh, cry, hold on tight, make it work for a little while/ Then one night her taillights fade out into the dark And a guy walks into a bar."