The less than 3-minute song makes good use of Derek Miller's signature heavy guitar licks. It also features Krauss rapping in a high pitched cartoon voice, threatening to put people's hearts in vices and dissing the American Dream. "It's a terrifying thing," she repeats throughout the song.

In the end though, Krauss does sort of contradict herself, letting everyone know there is at least one way to get a second chance: "Maybe baby, maybe if you ask me nice."