"We were at the nominations ceremony and we found out because there was someone with a camera right in our face right before they nominated us," Wesley Schultz confessed. "So we were pretty sure that we were in that category at that point because they had us sitting in the audience."

Though the band's not sure they'll actually be in attendance at the Grammys, they reflected on one of the show's most memorable moments from 1998.

"There's a Bob Dylan performance where he gets soy bombed by a man who comes out [with] 'Soy Bomb' written on his chest," Neyla Pekarek said. "I think Dylan handles it so well too he keeps going, it's great. It's very respectable."