The problem with most CD reviews is you only get the opinion of the one critic doing the review. So we thought it might be fun to try something new here by giving the exact same CD to two different critics (or more) and see what they each come up with and just how much difference a single critic's opinion can make. 

Note: due to the nature of this series, the reviews may tend to be more in the first person than you are used to with music criticism.

[ed note- This review marks the debut of Zane Ewton here at antiMUSIC. Welcome aboard Zane!]

Soulfly  - Prophecy
Label: Roadrunner Records
 

Tracks:
1. Prophecy
2. Living Sacrifice
3. Execution Style
4. Defeat U
5. Mars
6. I Believe
7. Moses
8. Born Again Anarchist
9. Porrada
10. In the Meantime
11. Soulfly IV
12. Wings

Zane Ewton's review - he gave it a rating of 

With Soulfly�s fourth release, lead entity Max Cavalera continues to mix the sounds of world music with the thrash of guitars.  Surprises are around every corner; while some are effective others left me scratching my head.

Cavalera continues to work with new people on every Soulfy album, most notable Dave Ellefson (ex-Megadeth) plays bass on several tracks. 

The revolving door of musicians is a blessing and a curse.  New people bring new ideas, but a lack of cohesion really hurts the album.  The tribal drums of past efforts are overshadowed by flashes of Spanish guitar that at times is delicate.  The focus on bringing new sounds and instruments into the mix seems to have taken the focus away from the guitars and the vocals.

There are some good riffs throughout Prophecy, but it is nothing the casual thrash metal fan hasn�t heard before. Cavalera keeps the lyrics simple.  Unfortunately the lyrics grow boring quickly with most songs being nothing more than a refrain.

Most songs on Prophecy seem to drag, and you will find yourself skipping to the next track after the initial intrigue of the song has worn off. 

One standout track is �Moses�.  A reggae beat that breaks into thrash fury is interesting and the most memorable moment of the album.  In the liner notes Cavalera mentions his title of �The Bob Marley of Metal�.  The only difference between the two is Marley�s ability to take a simple lyric and let it shine. 

You can feel that Cavalera�s experiments are going to give way to something much bigger but Prophecy feels like a detour on his exodus into a better realm.

Hobo's Review - He gave it a Rating of 

In 1996, Max Cavalera left one of the most popular heavy metal bands in the world � Sepultura. Upon his exit from the gigantean metal juggernaut, Max threw himself headlong into his new musical project, featuring Roy Mayorga (drums), Jackson Bandeira (guitar) and former Sepultura roadie Marcello D. Rapp (bass). This band would become known as the �ultra-heavy� (note: sarcasm) Soulfly.

The band formed with the best of intentions, releasing their tolerable self-titled debut album in 1998. But then something went horribly, horribly wrong. Max no longer looked to his death metal roots, but rather resorted to nu-metal type riffing and derivative lyrical content. 

After Soulfly�s two follow-up albums Primitive�(2000) and 3 (2002), Max had effectively isolated his massive Sepultura fan base.

For those of you who still pray for a rebirth of an inspired, invigorated Max � and I suspect there be close to none � I�m afraid your prayers are still to remain unanswered, as Prophecy is perhaps the single most horrible Soulfly album to date (well, in close enough contention with �3� to be considered abysmal). How can one even dare compare the Max of Sepultura�s Arise with the abominable s***-heap that is Soulfly? 

Truly, one cannot.

Prophecy illuminates Max�s waning song-writing ability, clear for all to see. The album itself is littered with fillers (in fact, every single track after the first can be considered a filler), what should have been powerful and meaningful bursts of metal have been replaced with extensively pointless, frustrating and infuriating introductions (and outros). 

Take for instance the horrible chorus line of �Execution Style�: �Ready, aim, fire. Ready, aim, fire.� (Repeat) Such pathetically uninspired and lifeless lyrics have become the defining features of a Soulfly album. �Mars� sports a similarly stale chorus (�I am Mars the god of war, you bow to me like you did before), complete with a THREE MINUTE AND FIFTEEN SECOND OUTRO. Excuse me? One hundred and ninety-five seconds of outro? This isn�t a goddam Tool album Max. 

Almost every track sounds like a dry and derivative echo of the past. For sake of example, �I Believe� acts as a boring-as-bats*** statement of Max�s beliefs, which goes for around six minutes longer that it should. The hands-down, standout, worst track of the album however is the track �Moses� � something of a spin-off of the 1998 album�s �Bumba� gone horribly, horribly, horribly wrong. �Moses, Moses where are you? Please! Show up, tell the children what to do� � followed up of course with another three-minute outro. How compelling! Awe-inspiring! 

Coming in a close second is �In The Meantime�, featuring some of the most appalling nu-metal riffing on the album, accompanied once more with a ninety second outro.  In �Born Again Anarchist� we can easily identify piss-poor repetitive lyrics, with a hopelessly muffled guitar sound, cleverly blended with YET ANOTHER f***ing unnecessarily long, drawn out, pointless outro.

In fact, the only listenable song on the album is the single � which if of course listed as the first track on the album � because Jod knows, with songs this piss poor, no man � now matter how foolish � would purchase this album after a single run of �Moses�.

Max has gone from God to git. He even stoops as low as to use the ULTRAH KEWL abbreviation for �you� in the title of �Defeat U�. 

This album should not be considered an album. It is a joke. A deeply saddening, disturbing and mournful prank played upon all us loyal metal fans by some macabre higher deity. Do not buy this album. Do not listen to this album. (Unless, of course, you�re of the Deftone-persuasion, then this kind of simplistic crock of nu-metal s***e would be right up your alley, asshats). 

Do yourself a favour and buy another copy of �Arise� in protest.
 
 

Listen to samples and Purchase this CD online


advertisement

advertisement

News Reports
Day in Rock:
Journey Icon Steve Perry Shares Video For Duet With His Late Father- Green Day, Post Malone and Lady Gaga Lead Coachella Lineup- more

Sammy Hagar's Theory On Why Alex Van Halen Didn't Accept Tour Invite- Aerosmith's Final Concert Streaming Online- more

Blink-182 Cancel Two Arena Shows Due To Illness- David Gilmour Shares 'Dark and Velvet Nights'- Ozzy, Lemmy, Motley Crue- more

AC/DC- Motion City Soundtrack End 10 Year Absence With 'Stop Talking'- Paul McCartney And Wings: One Hand Clapping, Rare Documentary Hitting Movie Theaters- more

Journey Cancels Fall Tour With Cheap Trick- Slipknot Party Like It's 1999 With Here Comes The Pain Tour Launch- more

Rammstein Say Allegations Are 'Baseless And Grossly Exaggerated' - Meshuggah's Jens Kidman Fuels 'The Last Ballad of Damrod'- Chicago Tour- more

Sammy Hagar Rocks Beatles Classic In Tribute To Aerosmith- Bryan Adams Rocks Classics KISS Songs That He Co-Wrote- more

Day in Pop:



Reviews

• Savoy Brown - Ain't Done Yet

• Quick Flicks: The Center of Nowhere (The Spirit and Sounds of Springfield, Missouri)

• Travel News, Trips and Tips: 100 Dishes to Eat in Alabama

• RockPile: Neal Smith, Shadow & the Thrill, Limousine Beach and Vicious Rooster

• The Georgia Thunderbolts - The Georgia Thunderbolts EP

• Ozzy Osborne Was The Monster Under My Bed

• Sites and Sounds: Slaughterhouse 5 Opera Set For September Premiere

• MorleyView: Deep Purple's Roger Glover

• Laura Wilde - Charmed + Dangerous

• RSC - Shadow Lady

• On The Record: Hall & Oates, Triumph, Daniel Johnston, and Social Distortion

• Sonic Fuel - I Will Rise

• Sites and Sounds: Texas Country At Sea

• The Blues: Albert Castiglia - Wild and Free

• Daddy1 - 1 Bro Gad

• RockPile: Gang of Four- Half Past Two - Venus Furs

• Travel News, Trips and Tips: Road Trip Gear Edition, Part 2

• Travel News, Trips and Tips: Road Trip Gear Part 1

• Static-X - Project Regeneration Volume 1

• Rock Reads: 'Run-Out Groove: Inside Capitol's 1980s Hits & Stiffs' by Dave Morrell

• Psycle - Kill The Machine

• RockPile: Southern Rock Edition - Lynyrd Skynyrd, Allman Bros, Molly Hatchet, Marshall Tucker Band

• RockPile: Danielia Cotton, the Jackets And More

• Root 66: Chicago Farmer - Flyover Country

• Reggae Party

• Sundogs - The Code

• Root 66: Nate Lee - Wings of a Jetliner

• Mallavora - The Paradise EP

• The Burrito Brothers - The Notorious Burrito Brothers

• David Cross & Peter Banks - Crossover

• Dennis DeYoung - 26 East: Volume 1 � more

Rock News Stories
Iron Maiden Legend Paul Di'Anno Laid To Rest

Watch Duran Duran Rock ELO's 'Evil Woman' At Madison Square Garden

The Amity Affliction Announce North American Tour

Jason Charles Miller Shares Video For Accidental Deep Purple Tribute

Lainey Wilson Wins CMA Female Vocalist Of The Year For 3rd Consecutive Year

Mac McAnally Sells Out His Ryman Auditorium Headline Debut

Dan Wilson Wins First CMA Award for Song of the Year For Chris Stapleton's 'White Horse'

Danjo Release 'Girls on the Dance Floor' Video

Watch Kacey Musgraves Perform 'The Architect' At The CMAs

Rodeo Mouth Take Fans To 'Fanny's Farmhouse'

KISS Army Marks 49th Anniversary

Yes Fire Back About Lawsuit Over Alleged Song Theft

Snoop Dogg To Headline Season Finale Of Amazon Music Live

BTS Star Jin Makes U.S. Solo TV Debut On The Tonight Show

Kesha Goes On 'JOYRIDE' With New Video

Nicki Minaj Adds Extended Verse To Juice WRLD's 'All Girls Are The Same 2 (Insecure)'

Travis Scott To Make Historical Return To Headline Coachella

Bear McCreary Announces First European Tour

George Porter Jr. (The Meters) Announces New Instrumental Album 'Porter's Pocket'

Paul Adams and Elizabeth Geyer Release the Album 'A Journey of Dreams'

Journey Icon Steve Perry Shares Video For Duet With His Late Father

George Harrison Early Beatles-Era Futurama Guitar Fetches $1.27 Million

Green Day, Post Malone and Lady Gaga Lead Coachella Lineup

Pistols At Dawn Rock Cover Of Wham's 'Last Christmas'

Lucero Stars Unplug For New Double Album Of Their Catalog Tracks

Sven Gali Give Red Rider's 'Lunatic Fringe' A Heavy Makeover

Drew & Ellie Holcomb Take 'High Seas' With New Song

Crazy Lixx Give Fans First Bite of New Album With 'Midnight Rebels' Video

Coliseum Remix and Remaster Debut Album For 20th Anniversary

Singled Out: Carolyn Broussard's Without You

� more

B-Side Stories
� more


Follow Us:

Contact Us - Privacy - antiMusic Email - Why we are antiMusic

Copyright© 1998 - 2016 Iconoclast Entertainment Group All rights reserved.

Please click here for legal restrictions and terms of use applicable to this site. Use of this site signifies your agreement to the terms of use.