Scarlet Hollow - What If Never Was

by Dan MacIntosh

What It Never Was () is Scarlet Hollow's second album, and is one squeaky clean audio product! It was produced by the band's own guitarist, Gregg Olson, who may also have a future career as a producer if the whole band thing doesn't work out. What sticks out most upon initial listening is just how smooth these instruments sound. It may be a rock album, due to the fact that it is built upon standard rock instrumentation, but there is nothing at all rough about it, which means you'll hear no dirty guitars or screamo vocals.

Scarlet Hollow's music falls into the progressive rock/metal genre, but what may be its most progressive element of all is the fact that the singer is a woman. Allison vonBuelow sings and writes lyrics to Scarlet Hollow songs, and also plays acoustic guitars and synths. The irony is not lost, by the way, that a genre with the forward-thinking name of ‘progressive' has so few female musicians, let alone lead vocalists. Perhaps, if Scarlet Hollow achieves widespread success, vonBuelow may inspire more women to enter into this mainly male-dominated style.

Progressive rock lyrics can sometimes veer a little too close to an overly dramatic Dungeons & Dragons game at times, but Scarlet Hollow keeps its songs grounded in reality. Singer vonBuelow has said that many of these songs tell the tale of a person's spiritual and emotional journey as they try to heal from the after effects of war." However, these song lyrics are rarely specific, so they can be interpreted in multiple ways. For instance, a title like Behind the Lines suggests battle associations, particularly when vonBuelow warns, Run, it is not safe here over a lovely acoustic guitar backing. Nevertheless, these words could describe almost any dire situation, from the battlefield to a violent romantic relationship.

Music performed by accomplished musicians, such as Scarlet Hollow, can appeal to diehards of the genre and novices alike because the playing goes beyond the ability to just shred, or ape Deep Purple riffs. Just listen to the pretty piano and jazzy guitar fills that highlight All That Remains. Also, vonBeulow gives one of her prettiest vocal performances on it. The track even includes thunderstorm sound effects, which are applied tastefully so as to not come off like an audio gimmick.

The only criticism that can be leveled at Scarlet Hollow is that a more linear storyline might have made this full-length a little more palatable. Perhaps, had the group realized sooner in the writing process that these songs were starting to form into a concept they could have solidified connections from song to song a little better. However, such issues do not at all take away from the quality of the music. It's difficult not to imagine Scarlet Hollow finding success in the progressive community because these musicians have the chops to make it.

Scarlet Hollow - What If Never Was

Share this article

More articles for this artist .



News Reports
Day in Rock:
Rock Has Reached A Dead End According To The Who's Daltrey- Yes Icon Rick Wakeman Disgusted By Rock Hall- Rolling Stones Play Private Gig For 300 People- more

Avenged Sevenfold Announce Virtual Reality Event- Megadeth's Dave Mustaine Unplugging For Christmas Show- Desert Trip Wasn't Great For Pete Townshend- Phil Collins- more

Van Halen and Michael Anthony Speak For First Time In A Decade- Dead Or Alive Frontman Pete Burns Dead At 57- Twenty One Pilots Concert Cut Short By Bomb Threat- more

Day in Pop:
Jon Bon Jovi Claims Rock Hall Mission To Snub Band- Lit Return With New Country Music Song 'Fast'- Phil Collins Performs 'In the Air Tonight' On Tonight Show- more

Metallica Release Acoustic 'Enter Sandman' Video- Suge Knight Sues Dr. Dre, Alleges Murder For Hire Plot- Guns N' Roses Stars At NFL Game- Taylor Swift Felt 'Violated'- more

Corey Taylor Was Forbidden From Joining Anthrax- Charlie Puth Cancels 'Don't Talk' Tour Due To Extreme Illness- Justin Bieber Walks Off Stage During UK Concert- more



• TBT: Metallica's Some Kind of Monster

• Savage Henry and the Infamous One Pounders - Get Off Easy

• The Survival Code - Broken Strings

• Grandpa Death Experience - The Unforgiving Shoe of the Future

• Rocktober Reads: Lou Gramm's Juke Box Hero: My Five Decades in Rock'n'Roll

• Rocktober Reads: Duff McKagan's It's So Easy (And Other Lies)

• Sites and Sounds: Jazz Fest Edition

• Rocktober Reads: Here, There and Everywhere: My Life Recording the Music of the Beatles

• Rocktober Reads: 'To Live Is To Die: The Life and Death of Metallica's Cliff Burton

• Rocktober Reads: Ozzy Osbourne's I Am Ozzy

• TBT: The Replacements - Don't You Know Who I Think I Was

• The Begowatts - Photoelectric

• Thy Catafalque - Sgurr

• Road Trip: Roots N Blues N BBQ Festival

• TBT Interview: Whitesnake's David Coverdale

• Almanac Mountain - Cryptoseismology

• Six Feet Under - Graveyard IV The Number of the Priest

• Sites and Sounds: Wire & Wood Songwriters Festival

• Dio - Holy Diver

• Rock Reads: Dynamic Song Performance: The Singers Bible

• Iron Savior - Titancraft

• Root 66: Doyle Lawson and Quicksilver - Burden Bearer • more

Rock News Stories
• Rock Has Reached A Dead End According To The Who's Daltrey

• Yes Icon Rick Wakeman Disgusted By Rock Hall

• Rolling Stones Play Private Gig For 300 People

• Reunited Asking Alexandria Already Recorded New Music

• Iron Maiden Stand Against Pay For Play Practice

• Prince, Rolling Stones, Jack White Record Store Day Exclusives

• Korn Release 'Take Me' Video

• For Today Members Launch New Band, Stream First Song

• Tom Petty Announces 40th Anniversary Box Sets

• Scorpions Energized By Addition Of Motorhead's Mikkey Dee

• Evergrey Recruit Floor Jansen For 'In Orbit' Video

• Enslaved Stream New Song 'Heimvegen'

• Rick Parfitt Rules Out Return To Status Quo

• Bob Seger In The Studio For Night Moves 40th Anniversary

• Protest The Hero Stream New Song 'Harbinger'

• Crowbar Going Old School With Todd Strange

• Knifeworld Release 'I Must Set Fire To Your Portrait' Video

• Singled Out: The World Over's Mountains

• more

B-Side Stories
• Jon Bon Jovi Claims Rock Hall Mission To Snub Band

• Lit Return With New Country Music Song 'Fast'

• Phil Collins Performs 'In the Air Tonight' On Tonight Show

• Mariah Carey Cancels Sweet Sweet Fantasy Tour Leg

• Kid Cudi's Manager Slams Drake Over Alleged Diss Track

• Neil Young Announces New Album 'Peace Trail'

• Virtual Reality ABBA Coming

• ASAP Mob Releasing 'Cozy Tapes Vol 1' On Halloween

• Britney Spears Collaborates With Tinashe In The Studio

• Katy Perry Shades Taylor Swift at Kanye West Concert

• Tom Hanks Recreates Rap From 'Big'

• Lady Gaga Appears On 'Carpool Karaoke'

• more

Follow Us:

Contact Us - Privacy - antiMusic Email - Why we are antiMusic

Copyright© 1998 - 2016 Iconoclast Entertainment Group All rights reserved.

Please click here for legal restrictions and terms of use applicable to this site. Use of this site signifies your agreement to the terms of use.