The track bides from Peter Gabriel's "In Your Eyes," with the sisters Haim manning the drums and harmonizing sweetly about the one who got away. Though Twin Shadow didn't make it on their debut, they did get a little help from Jessie Ware who co-wrote the title track with them.

In an interview with Radio.com, the sisters revealed that after a five-hour lunch, where they talked about everything from rollerblading to finding a place in L.A. where they could all live together, the song came together.